How Much Is Procreate? Pricing, Features, and Alternatives

Procreate, the leading creative application for iPad, is a powerful tool for artists. Understanding its pricing, features, and alternatives is crucial. HOW.EDU.VN provides expert guidance, helping you to make the best choice for your artistic needs. Explore digital painting, digital illustration, and graphic design options with our assistance.

1. Understanding Procreate: An Overview

Procreate is a raster graphics editor app for digital painting. It is designed for and available on iPadOS. Developed and published by Savage Interactive, it is known for its intuitive interface, extensive brush library, and powerful tools suitable for both professional artists and hobbyists. The app supports high-resolution canvases, advanced layering systems, and features like QuickShape and drawing assist, making it a comprehensive digital art studio.

1.1 Key Features of Procreate

Procreate boasts a range of features tailored to enhance the digital art creation process:

  • High-Resolution Canvases: Supports canvases up to 16K by 8K on compatible iPad Pros.
  • Intuitive Interface: Designed specifically for iPad and Apple Pencil.
  • QuickShape Feature: Allows for the creation of perfect shapes.
  • Brush Library: Offers hundreds of handmade brushes with customizable settings.
  • Layering System: Provides precise control over details and composition.
  • Valkyrie Engine: A lightning-fast 64-bit painting engine.
  • 3D Painting: Supports painting with lighting studio, exportable as models, images, or animations.
  • Time-Lapse Replay: Records and allows exporting of time-lapse videos of the creative process.
  • Import/Export: Supports various file formats, including PSD, JPG, PNG, TIFF, and PDF.

1.2 Target Audience of Procreate

Procreate caters to a broad audience, including:

  • Professional Artists: Illustrators, designers, and animators who require a robust and portable digital art tool.
  • Hobbyists: Individuals who enjoy creating digital art for personal enjoyment.
  • Students: Art and design students learning the fundamentals of digital painting and illustration.
  • Educators: Teachers and instructors looking for a versatile app for art education.
  • Graphic designers: Digital artists working on creative advertising.

2. Procreate Pricing: How Much Does It Cost?

One of the most appealing aspects of Procreate is its straightforward pricing model. Unlike many subscription-based software options, Procreate is available for a one-time purchase fee.

2.1 The One-Time Purchase Model

Procreate follows a one-time purchase model. This means that you pay a single fee to download and use the app indefinitely.

  • Current Price: The current price for Procreate is $12.99 USD on the Apple App Store.
  • No Subscription Fees: There are no recurring subscription fees, making it a cost-effective option in the long run.
  • Updates Included: The one-time purchase includes all future updates and enhancements to the app.

2.2 Factors Influencing the Cost

While the price of the Procreate app itself is fixed, there are other factors to consider that can influence the overall cost:

  • iPad Device: Procreate is exclusively available for iPadOS, so you will need an iPad device. The cost of an iPad can range from a few hundred dollars for a basic model to over a thousand dollars for a high-end iPad Pro.
  • Apple Pencil: While not strictly required, the Apple Pencil is highly recommended for the best Procreate experience. It offers pressure sensitivity and tilt support, allowing for more natural and precise drawing and painting. The Apple Pencil is sold separately and costs around $99 to $129 USD, depending on the generation.
  • Accessories: Other accessories like a screen protector, case, or stand can add to the overall cost.
  • Additional Brushes and Resources: While Procreate comes with a vast library of brushes, some artists may choose to purchase additional brush packs or resources from third-party vendors.

2.3 Procreate Pocket for iPhone

In addition to the main Procreate app for iPad, there is also Procreate Pocket, designed for iPhone.

  • Procreate Pocket: A mobile version of Procreate, offering many of the same features and tools on a smaller screen.
  • Pricing: Procreate Pocket is also available for a one-time purchase fee, typically priced around $4.99 USD.
  • Features: It includes features like multiple layers, custom brushes, and advanced color controls.

2.4 Cost Comparison: Procreate vs. Subscription-Based Software

When comparing Procreate’s pricing to subscription-based software, the long-term cost benefits become clear.

Software Pricing Model Initial Cost Recurring Cost Long-Term Cost (3 Years)
Procreate One-Time Purchase $12.99 $0 $12.99
Adobe Photoshop Subscription $0 $20.99/month $755.64
Clip Studio Paint Subscription/One-Time $49.99 $4.49/month $211.63
Affinity Photo One-Time Purchase $69.99 $0 $69.99
Autodesk Sketchbook Pro Subscription $0 $85/year $255

As the table illustrates, Procreate offers significant savings over time compared to subscription-based alternatives.

3. Procreate Features: A Deep Dive

Procreate is renowned for its comprehensive suite of features designed to meet the needs of digital artists.

3.1 Brush System

The brush system in Procreate is one of its standout features, offering a vast array of options for creating unique and expressive strokes.

  • Hundreds of Brushes: Procreate comes with hundreds of pre-made brushes, ranging from pencils and inks to paints and special effects brushes.
  • Customizable Settings: Each brush can be customized with over 100 settings, allowing artists to fine-tune the brush behavior to their exact preferences.
  • Brush Studio: Procreate’s Brush Studio allows users to create their own custom brushes from scratch.
  • Import Brushes: Users can import custom brushes created by other artists or downloaded from online resources.
  • Adobe Photoshop Brush Support: Procreate supports importing and running Adobe Photoshop brushes, expanding the available brush library.

3.2 Layering System

Procreate’s layering system is a powerful tool for organizing and manipulating different elements of a digital artwork.

  • Non-Destructive Editing: Layers allow for non-destructive editing, meaning that changes made to one layer do not affect other layers.
  • Layer Masks and Clipping Masks: Layer Masks and Clipping Masks provide additional control over layer visibility and effects.
  • Layer Groups: Layers can be combined into groups for better organization and easier management.
  • Blend Modes: Procreate offers over 25 layer blend modes for creating various effects and compositing.
  • Multiple Layer Selection: Multiple layers can be selected and transformed simultaneously.

3.3 Color Tools

Procreate offers a variety of color tools to help artists achieve the perfect color palette and apply colors effectively.

  • ColorDrop and SwatchDrop: Quickly fill line work with ColorDrop and SwatchDrop features.
  • Color Panels: Access color panels in Disc, Classic, Harmony, Value, and Palette modes.
  • Color Profiles: Import color profiles for accurate color matching.
  • Color Dynamics: Assign color dynamics to any brush for unique effects.

3.4 Drawing and Design Aids

Procreate includes several drawing and design aids to assist artists in creating precise and accurate artwork.

  • QuickShape: Create perfect shapes with the QuickShape feature.
  • Perspective, Isometric, 2D, and Symmetry Guides: Use visual guides for perspective, isometric, 2D, and symmetry drawing.
  • Drawing Assist: Drawing Assist perfects strokes in real-time.
  • StreamLine and Stabilization: Smooth strokes with StreamLine and stabilization features.
  • Scribble: Use Scribble to name layers, change settings, and create text.
  • Add Vector Text: Incorporate vector text into illustrations.

3.5 Animation and Page Assist

Procreate also includes features for creating animations and multi-page documents.

  • Frame-by-Frame Animation: Create frame-by-frame animations with customizable onion skinning.
  • Page Assist: Sketch page-by-page concepts or begin a comic with Page Assist.
  • Import and Edit PDFs: Import, edit, and share PDFs.

3.6 Special Effects and Adjustments

Procreate offers a range of special effects and adjustments to enhance digital artwork.

  • Brush-In Adjustments and Effects: Apply image adjustments and effects with Apple Pencil.
  • Glitch, Chromatic Aberration, Bloom, Noise, and Halftone: Add new dimensions to artwork with these effects.
  • Gaussian, Motion, and Perspective Blur: Create depth and movement with blur filters.
  • Image Adjustments: Powerful image adjustments, including Color Balance, Curves, HSB, and Gradient Map.
  • Warp, Symmetry, and Liquify Dynamics: Bring art to life with these creative dynamics.

3.7 Accessibility Features

Procreate includes accessibility features to make the app more usable for individuals with disabilities.

  • Advanced Stroke Stabilization: Stabilize strokes for smoother lines.
  • Dynamic Type, VoiceOver, and Feedback Sounds: Enhanced support for users with visual impairments.
  • Assignable Single-Touch Gestures: Customize gestures for easier navigation.
  • Color Naming: Assign names to colors for better organization and communication.

4. Procreate Alternatives: Exploring Other Options

While Procreate is a top-tier digital art app, several alternatives offer similar features and capabilities.

4.1 Adobe Photoshop

Adobe Photoshop is the industry-standard image editing and graphic design software.

  • Overview: Photoshop offers a wide range of tools for photo editing, digital painting, and graphic design.
  • Pricing: Available through Adobe Creative Cloud subscription, starting at $20.99/month.
  • Pros: Comprehensive feature set, industry-standard, cross-platform compatibility.
  • Cons: Subscription-based, steeper learning curve, can be resource-intensive.

4.2 Adobe Fresco

Adobe Fresco is a digital painting and drawing app designed for iPad and other touch devices.

  • Overview: Fresco combines the power of Photoshop brushes with vector brushes for versatile drawing and painting.
  • Pricing: Included with some Adobe Creative Cloud subscriptions or available as a standalone subscription.
  • Pros: Integration with Adobe Creative Cloud, live brushes, user-friendly interface.
  • Cons: Subscription-based, fewer features than Photoshop.

4.3 Clip Studio Paint

Clip Studio Paint is a popular digital painting and illustration software, particularly favored by comic artists and illustrators.

  • Overview: Offers a range of tools for creating comics, illustrations, and animations.
  • Pricing: Available as a one-time purchase or subscription.
  • Pros: Specialized tools for comic creation, extensive brush library, affordable options.
  • Cons: Interface can be overwhelming for beginners, some features require a subscription.

4.4 Affinity Photo

Affinity Photo is a professional photo editing software that offers a range of features similar to Adobe Photoshop.

  • Overview: Powerful photo editing tools, non-destructive editing, and support for various file formats.
  • Pricing: Available as a one-time purchase.
  • Pros: Affordable, feature-rich, no subscription required.
  • Cons: Steeper learning curve than some other apps, fewer specialized tools for digital painting.

4.5 Autodesk Sketchbook

Autodesk Sketchbook is a free digital painting and drawing app designed for sketching and concept art.

  • Overview: Offers a clean and intuitive interface with a range of sketching and drawing tools.
  • Pricing: Free for personal use.
  • Pros: Free, user-friendly, suitable for sketching and concept art.
  • Cons: Fewer advanced features than paid alternatives.

4.6 ArtRage

ArtRage is a digital painting program that focuses on simulating traditional painting techniques.

  • Overview: Offers realistic paint mixing and blending, with tools like oil brushes, watercolors, and palette knives.
  • Pricing: Available as a one-time purchase.
  • Pros: Realistic painting simulation, intuitive interface, affordable.
  • Cons: Fewer features for graphic design and illustration.

4.7 Krita

Krita is a free and open-source digital painting program designed for concept art, illustration, and animation.

  • Overview: Offers a range of advanced features, including brush stabilization, layer management, and animation tools.
  • Pricing: Free and open-source.
  • Pros: Free, feature-rich, customizable interface.
  • Cons: Steeper learning curve, may require more powerful hardware.

4.8 Corel Painter

Corel Painter is a professional digital painting program that focuses on simulating traditional art media.

  • Overview: Offers a wide range of realistic brushes and painting tools, with advanced features like particle brushes and texture synthesis.
  • Pricing: Available as a one-time purchase or subscription.
  • Pros: Realistic painting simulation, extensive brush library, industry-standard.
  • Cons: Expensive, can be resource-intensive.

4.9 Comparison Table of Procreate Alternatives

Software Pricing Key Features Pros Cons
Adobe Photoshop Subscription Photo editing, graphic design, digital painting Industry-standard, comprehensive features Subscription-based, resource-intensive
Adobe Fresco Subscription Digital painting, live brushes, vector brushes Integration with Adobe Creative Cloud, user-friendly interface Subscription-based, fewer features than Photoshop
Clip Studio Paint One-Time/Subscription Comic creation, illustration, animation Specialized tools for comic creation, extensive brush library Interface can be overwhelming, some features require a subscription
Affinity Photo One-Time Photo editing, non-destructive editing Affordable, feature-rich Steeper learning curve, fewer specialized tools for digital painting
Autodesk Sketchbook Free Sketching, concept art Free, user-friendly Fewer advanced features than paid alternatives
ArtRage One-Time Realistic painting simulation Realistic painting simulation, intuitive interface Fewer features for graphic design and illustration
Krita Free Concept art, illustration, animation Free, feature-rich, customizable interface Steeper learning curve, may require more powerful hardware
Corel Painter One-Time/Subscription Realistic painting simulation, particle brushes, texture synthesis Realistic painting simulation, extensive brush library Expensive, can be resource-intensive

5. Procreate System Requirements and Compatibility

To ensure a smooth and optimal experience with Procreate, it is essential to be aware of the system requirements and compatibility.

5.1 iPadOS Compatibility

Procreate is exclusively available for iPadOS. The app is compatible with a wide range of iPad models, but performance may vary depending on the device’s hardware capabilities.

  • Supported Devices: Procreate is compatible with iPad Pro, iPad Air, iPad, and iPad mini models that support iPadOS 14 or later.
  • Optimal Performance: For the best performance, it is recommended to use Procreate on newer iPad Pro models with powerful processors and ample RAM.
  • Storage Requirements: Procreate requires a minimum amount of storage space for installation and storing artwork. The amount of storage needed will depend on the size and complexity of the projects.

5.2 Apple Pencil Support

The Apple Pencil is highly recommended for use with Procreate, as it offers pressure sensitivity, tilt support, and low latency, which enhance the drawing and painting experience.

  • Apple Pencil (1st Generation): Compatible with older iPad models.
  • Apple Pencil (2nd Generation): Compatible with newer iPad Pro and iPad Air models.

5.3 Hardware Considerations

When choosing an iPad for Procreate, consider the following hardware factors:

  • Processor: A powerful processor ensures smooth performance, especially when working with large canvases and complex artwork.
  • RAM: Ample RAM allows for handling multiple layers and high-resolution images without performance issues.
  • Storage: Sufficient storage space is essential for storing artwork, brushes, and other resources.
  • Display: A high-quality display with accurate color reproduction is important for visual accuracy and detail.

5.4 Software Updates

Regularly updating to the latest version of iPadOS and Procreate is crucial for accessing the latest features, bug fixes, and performance improvements.

  • iPadOS Updates: Keep your iPadOS updated to ensure compatibility and access to the latest system-level enhancements.
  • Procreate Updates: Enable automatic updates for Procreate in the App Store to receive the latest features and improvements.

6. Learning Procreate: Resources and Tutorials

For those new to Procreate or looking to improve their skills, numerous resources and tutorials are available.

6.1 Official Procreate Resources

Savage Interactive, the developer of Procreate, provides several official resources to help users learn and master the app.

  • Procreate Handbook: A comprehensive user manual that covers all aspects of the app, from basic features to advanced techniques.
  • Procreate Website: The official Procreate website offers tutorials, articles, and community forums.
  • Procreate Forums: A community forum where users can ask questions, share artwork, and exchange tips and tricks.

6.2 Online Courses and Tutorials

Many online platforms offer courses and tutorials on Procreate.

  • Skillshare: Offers a wide range of Procreate courses taught by experienced artists.
  • Udemy: Provides Procreate courses for beginners to advanced users.
  • Domestika: Offers creative courses, including Procreate tutorials.
  • YouTube: Numerous YouTube channels provide free Procreate tutorials and tips.

6.3 Community and Social Media

Engaging with the Procreate community and following artists on social media can provide inspiration and learning opportunities.

  • Instagram: Follow Procreate artists and hashtags to discover new techniques and inspiration.
  • Facebook Groups: Join Procreate-related Facebook groups to connect with other users and share artwork.
  • Twitter: Follow Procreate artists and industry experts on Twitter for tips and news.

6.4 Books and Publications

Several books and publications offer in-depth guidance on using Procreate.

  • “Procreate User Guide” by Savage Interactive: A comprehensive guide to all of Procreate’s features.
  • “The Ultimate Guide to Procreate” by various authors: A collection of tutorials and tips for using Procreate.
  • “Digital Painting with Procreate” by Elizabeth Briggs: A step-by-step guide to creating digital paintings in Procreate.

6.5 Tips for Learning Procreate

Here are some tips for effectively learning Procreate:

  • Start with the Basics: Begin by familiarizing yourself with the app’s interface and basic tools.
  • Follow Tutorials: Watch tutorials to learn specific techniques and workflows.
  • Experiment with Brushes: Try out different brushes to discover their unique effects.
  • Practice Regularly: Consistent practice is essential for improving your skills.
  • Join the Community: Engage with the Procreate community to ask questions and share your work.
  • Set Goals: Set specific goals for your learning, such as mastering a particular technique or creating a certain type of artwork.
  • Be Patient: Learning Procreate takes time and effort, so be patient and persistent.

7. Procreate for Professional Use

Procreate has become a popular tool for professional artists and designers due to its versatility, portability, and powerful features.

7.1 Illustration and Design

Procreate is widely used for creating illustrations, logos, and other design elements.

  • Digital Illustration: Many illustrators use Procreate to create detailed and expressive artwork for books, magazines, and online media.
  • Logo Design: Procreate’s vector text and precise drawing tools make it suitable for logo design.
  • Graphic Design: Procreate can be used for creating graphics for websites, social media, and marketing materials.

7.2 Animation

Procreate’s animation features allow artists to create frame-by-frame animations and animated GIFs.

  • Character Animation: Animators use Procreate to create character animations for cartoons, video games, and other media.
  • Motion Graphics: Procreate can be used for creating motion graphics for video projects.
  • Animated GIFs: Procreate’s animation tools make it easy to create animated GIFs for social media and marketing.

7.3 Concept Art and Storyboarding

Procreate is a popular tool for creating concept art and storyboards for films, video games, and other media.

  • Concept Art: Concept artists use Procreate to create visual representations of ideas and designs.
  • Storyboarding: Procreate’s Page Assist feature makes it easy to create storyboards for visualizing scenes and sequences.

7.4 Professional Workflow Integration

Procreate can be integrated into professional workflows using various file formats and export options.

  • PSD Export: Procreate supports exporting artwork as PSD files, which can be opened in Adobe Photoshop for further editing.
  • PNG and JPEG Export: Procreate can export artwork as PNG and JPEG files for use in websites, social media, and other applications.
  • PDF Export: Procreate can export multi-page documents as PDF files for sharing and printing.

7.5 Case Studies of Professional Use

Many professional artists and designers have shared their experiences using Procreate in their work.

  • Illustrator Kyle Lambert: Known for creating the poster for the Netflix series “Stranger Things” using Procreate.
  • Comic Artist Dave Gibbons: Uses Procreate to create comic book art and illustrations.
  • Concept Artist Lorraine Warren: Uses Procreate to create concept art for video games and films.

8. Troubleshooting Common Procreate Issues

While Procreate is a reliable app, users may encounter occasional issues. Here are some common problems and their solutions.

8.1 Performance Issues

Performance issues, such as lag or crashes, can occur if the iPad’s hardware is not powerful enough or if the artwork is too complex.

  • Reduce Canvas Size: Reduce the canvas size to improve performance.
  • Limit Layers: Limit the number of layers in the artwork.
  • Close Other Apps: Close other apps running in the background to free up memory.
  • Restart iPad: Restart the iPad to clear temporary files and refresh the system.
  • Update Procreate: Ensure that Procreate is updated to the latest version.

8.2 Brush Issues

Brush issues, such as brushes not working or behaving unexpectedly, can occur due to various reasons.

  • Reset Brush Settings: Reset the brush settings to their default values.
  • Check Brush Opacity and Size: Ensure that the brush opacity and size are set correctly.
  • Import Brushes Correctly: Make sure that custom brushes are imported correctly.
  • Restart Procreate: Restart Procreate to refresh the brush library.

8.3 Export Issues

Export issues, such as files not exporting or exporting with errors, can occur due to file size or format issues.

  • Reduce File Size: Reduce the file size by flattening layers or reducing the resolution.
  • Check File Format: Ensure that the file format is supported by the target application.
  • Export to Different Format: Try exporting to a different file format.
  • Restart Procreate: Restart Procreate to clear temporary files.

8.4 Apple Pencil Issues

Apple Pencil issues, such as the Pencil not working or experiencing connectivity problems, can disrupt the workflow.

  • Check Apple Pencil Connection: Ensure that the Apple Pencil is properly connected to the iPad.
  • Restart iPad: Restart the iPad to refresh the Bluetooth connection.
  • Replace Apple Pencil Tip: Replace the Apple Pencil tip if it is damaged or worn out.
  • Update iPadOS: Ensure that iPadOS is updated to the latest version.

8.5 Common Error Messages

Users may encounter error messages while using Procreate. Here are some common error messages and their solutions.

  • “Not Enough Memory”: Close other apps and reduce the canvas size.
  • “File Corrupted”: Try opening the file on a different iPad or reinstall Procreate.
  • “Export Failed”: Reduce the file size and try exporting to a different format.

9. Optimizing Procreate for Different Art Styles

Procreate’s versatility allows it to be optimized for various art styles, from realistic painting to stylized illustration.

9.1 Realistic Painting

To optimize Procreate for realistic painting:

  • Use Blending Brushes: Use blending brushes to create smooth transitions and realistic textures.
  • Experiment with Layer Blend Modes: Use layer blend modes to create realistic lighting and shadows.
  • Use Reference Images: Use reference images to accurately capture details and proportions.
  • Work in High Resolution: Work in high resolution to capture fine details.

9.2 Stylized Illustration

To optimize Procreate for stylized illustration:

  • Use Line Art Brushes: Use line art brushes to create clean and crisp lines.
  • Experiment with Color Palettes: Use a limited color palette to create a cohesive and stylized look.
  • Use Shapes and Silhouettes: Use shapes and silhouettes to create interesting compositions.
  • Exaggerate Features: Exaggerate features to create a unique and stylized character.

9.3 Comic Book Art

To optimize Procreate for comic book art:

  • Use Ink Brushes: Use ink brushes to create bold and dynamic lines.
  • Use Halftone Patterns: Use halftone patterns to add texture and depth.
  • Create Panels and Layouts: Use Procreate’s drawing guides to create panels and layouts.
  • Add Dialogue and Sound Effects: Add dialogue and sound effects using vector text tools.

9.4 Concept Art

To optimize Procreate for concept art:

  • Use Sketching Brushes: Use sketching brushes to quickly generate ideas and concepts.
  • Experiment with Lighting and Shadows: Use lighting and shadows to create mood and atmosphere.
  • Use Texture Overlays: Use texture overlays to add detail and realism.
  • Work Iteratively: Work iteratively, refining the design over multiple stages.

9.5 Graphic Design

To optimize Procreate for graphic design:

  • Use Vector Text Tools: Use vector text tools to create clean and scalable text.
  • Create Shapes and Icons: Create shapes and icons using Procreate’s drawing guides.
  • Use Color Palettes: Use color palettes to create a cohesive and professional look.
  • Export as Vector Files: Export as vector files for use in other design applications.

10. Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) About Procreate

Here are some frequently asked questions about Procreate:

Q1: How much does Procreate cost?

Procreate costs $12.99 USD as a one-time purchase on the Apple App Store.

Q2: Is Procreate available for Android devices?

No, Procreate is exclusively available for iPadOS.

Q3: Do I need an Apple Pencil to use Procreate?

While not strictly required, the Apple Pencil is highly recommended for the best Procreate experience.

Q4: Can I import Adobe Photoshop brushes into Procreate?

Yes, Procreate supports importing and running Adobe Photoshop brushes.

Q5: Can I create animations in Procreate?

Yes, Procreate includes features for creating frame-by-frame animations.

Q6: What file formats does Procreate support?

Procreate supports various file formats, including PSD, JPG, PNG, TIFF, and PDF.

Q7: How do I update Procreate?

You can update Procreate through the App Store on your iPad.

Q8: Is there a free trial of Procreate?

No, there is no free trial of Procreate, but you can explore Procreate Pocket for iPhone.

Q9: Can I use Procreate for commercial projects?

Yes, you can use Procreate for commercial projects.

Q10: Where can I find tutorials and resources for learning Procreate?

You can find tutorials and resources on the official Procreate website, Skillshare, Udemy, YouTube, and other online platforms.

Navigating the world of digital art can be complex, but understanding the cost and capabilities of tools like Procreate is essential for success. At HOW.EDU.VN, we connect you with experts who can guide you in making informed decisions for your creative journey. Whether you need advice on software, hardware, or techniques, our team of over 100 PhDs is here to provide personalized and reliable support. Contact us today at 456 Expertise Plaza, Consult City, CA 90210, United States, Whatsapp: +1 (310) 555-1212, or visit our website at how.edu.vn to discover how we can help you achieve your artistic goals.

Comments

No comments yet. Why don’t you start the discussion?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *